7 Underdog Movies Like Sling Blade For Late Success Joe Rogan

Sling Blade proved one thing: you do not need a $200 million budget or a 22-year-old face to make a masterpiece. Billy Bob Thornton wrote, directed, and starred in the 1996 film at age 41 with $380,000 and 24 days. The result: an Oscar, $24 million at the box office, and a career that finally let him keep the Arkansas accent.

On The Joe Rogan Experience episode 2407 (November 7, 2025), Thornton called it “the best thing that ever happened to me—because it happened late.” Below are seven more underdog movies that followed the same blueprint: low budget, older creators, raw stories, and massive payoff. Each one is a masterclass in late-blooming success—no child stars, no studio polish, just grit and a camera.

1. The Blair Witch Project (1999) – $60,000 Budget, $248 Million Box Office

Filmmakers Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sánchez were 30 and 31. They shot in eight days with a Hi8 camcorder in the Maryland woods. Three unknown actors improvised most of the dialogue. The marketing hoax—“these kids are missing”—went viral before viral existed. The film invented found-footage horror and turned $60K into a quarter-billion. Late? No. But proof passion beats polish.

2. Paranormal Activity (2007) – $15,000 Budget, $193 Million Box Office

Oren Peli was 35, an unemployed video game designer. He shot the entire movie in his own house over seven days with two actors and a $200 camera from Best Buy. Steven Spielberg saw a screener and pushed for theatrical release. The film launched a franchise worth $890 million. Peli never went to film school. He just stayed up late.

3. Primer (2004) – $7,000 Budget, Sundance Grand Jury Prize

Shane Carruth was 32, a former engineer. He wrote, directed, edited, scored, and starred in a time-travel puzzle shot on 16mm in his parents’ garage. The math is real. The budget is not. Primer won at Sundance and became a cult classic for anyone who loves a headache. Carruth funded it with credit cards. He still owns the negative.

4. Napoleon Dynamite (2004) – $400,000 Budget, $46 Million Box Office

Jared Hess was 25 when he shot it, but the cast was older and unknown. Jon Heder (24) lived in his parents’ basement. The film was made in 22 days in Preston, Idaho, with a $400K loan from a local dentist. It became a cultural phenomenon—t-shirts, dance moves, and a TV series. Hess kept final cut. Fox Searchlight paid $3 million for distribution.

5. Once (2007) – $150,000 Budget, Oscar for Best Original Song

John Carney was 35, a failed musician. He shot in 17 days on the streets of Dublin with Glen Hansard (37) and Markéta Irglová (19, but the soul was older). No permits. Real buses. Real rain. The song “Falling Slowly” won the Oscar. The film cost pocket change and grossed $20 million. Carney funded it with savings from music videos.

6. The Full Monty (1997) – $3.5 Million Budget, $258 Million Box Office

Peter Cattaneo was 34. The script came from a unemployed steelworker’s story. Shot in six weeks in Sheffield, England, with six middle-aged actors who had never led a film. The striptease scene was rehearsed in a church hall. It beat Titanic at the BAFTAs and became the highest-grossing British film ever at the time. Proof dad bods can dance.

7. Little Miss Sunshine (2006) – $8 Million Budget, $101 Million Box Office

Directors Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris were 47 and 48. They shot in 30 days across the California desert with a VW bus that actually broke down on cue. The cast: Steve Carell (44), Alan Arkin (72), Abigail Breslin (10). The script sat in development hell for five years. Focus Features picked it up. Two Oscars. One perfect road trip.

The Sling Blade Blueprint They All Followed

Every film above used the same five rules Thornton lived by:  

1. Shoot where you’re from – Real locations, real accents, real stakes.
2. Cast unknowns or late-bloomers – No ego, no salary demands.  
3. Keep the budget under $10 million – Less money, more freedom.  
4. Own the edit – Final cut is the only cut that matters.  
5. Tell a human story – Audiences smell fake from a mile away.  

The Numbers Don’t Lie

• Average budget: $1.9 million
• Average box office: $123 million  
• Average ROI: 6,400%
• Average age of key creator at release: 37  

Compare that to Marvel’s $200M flops and tell me who’s winning.

Why Late Success Tastes Better

Thornton told Rogan: “At 41, I didn’t need the spotlight. I needed the story.” These films prove it. No one was chasing trends. No one was 22 and invincible. They were hungry, broke, and old enough to know the clock was ticking. That urgency made magic.

Where to Watch

- Sling Blade – Paramount+  
- The Blair Witch Project – Hulu  
- Paranormal Activity – Paramount+  
- Primer – Tubi (free)  
- Napoleon Dynamite – Disney+  
- Once – Rent on Amazon  
- The Full Monty – Hulu  
- Little Miss Sunshine – Hulu  

Your Turn

Got $400K and 24 days? Write the script. Call your cousin. Steal your mom’s camcorder. The next Sling Blade is waiting in your garage.

RELATED:

Billy Bob Thornton On Fame At 40 Vs 20 Joe Rogan Advice

Why Billy Bob Thornton Wants a Common Sense Party in Hollywood