The Secret Behind The Sauce: How Leslie Ann Woodward’s Creation Became A Chick-fil-A Icon

In the world of fast food, few condiments have reached the cult status of Chick-fil-A Sauce. Beloved for its rich, tangy, and slightly sweet flavor, the sauce has become a must-have for millions of customers. But while many assume it was born in a corporate test kitchen, the real story is far more intriguing—and deeply personal for Leslie Ann Woodward.

Before Woodward graced international runways, she was a teenager working behind the counter at Chick-fil-A in Spotsylvania Mall, Fredericksburg, Virginia. From 1981 to 1986, she took orders, prepped food, and—without realizing it—created one of the most famous fast-food sauces in history.

At just 15 years old, she was approached by her manager, Hugh Fleming, with an unusual task: come up with a sauce to pair with their chicken nuggets. At the time, Chick-fil-A didn’t officially sell nuggets, but Fleming had come up with an innovative workaround. By pinching off corners of their chicken breasts, they crafted bite-sized pieces and served them in foil sandwich bags, handwriting "nuggets" on the menu board.

The nuggets were good. But they needed something extra.

Woodward, always eager for a challenge, took the assignment seriously. She spent late nights experimenting in the kitchen after closing, staying long after mopping the floors to perfect her creation. It took many tries. Many fails. She pulled ingredients from what was available in the kitchen—each one there for a reason. Honey, because Kathleen, an older employee who made lemon pies in the mornings, liked it in her tea. Barbecue sauce, because the store’s barbecue chicken sandwich came with more sauce than chicken, and Woodward had grown to love its smoky taste.

Finally, she got it right.

The result? Customers couldn’t get enough. They brought their own containers to fill with the sauce. They returned just for it. But back then, it was given away for free.

Everything changed the day Chick-fil-A’s corporate executives made a surprise visit to the Spotsylvania Mall location. It was a huge deal.

Fleming saw an opportunity—his unofficial nuggets would be the highlight. The sauce? That was just a side note.

“I remember standing there in my uniform, so proud,” Woodward recalls. “At the first taste of my sauce, the whole room just became mine. They raved about it. And in that moment, I felt something shift—I felt important. I was just a tall, awkward girl in a small Virginia town, but suddenly, I saw possibilities.” She never imagined that moment would follow her for the rest of her life.

Years later, Woodward left Virginia in 1989 to pursue a modeling career in Europe. But on a visit home, she made a shocking discovery. Ordering her usual meal at Chick-fil-A, she instinctively dipped into a packet of their signature Chick-fil-A Sauce and froze.

“My eyes went wider than they’d ever been,” she remembers. “I looked at my mom and said, ‘This is my sauce.’”

Her mother barely flinched. In true Southern fashion, she offered a calm but pointed warning.

“I know. DON’T make a fuss.”

Woodward rolled her eyes. Of course, her mother would say that. She had spent a lifetime trying to guide her fearless, big-dreaming daughter to stay small, to avoid stirring up trouble.

“You don’t want to have all of Chick-fil-A coming after you to discredit you,” she added.

And maybe she was right. Woodward had no idea how to defend herself back then. And the truth was, the man credited with the sauce—Hugh Fleming—was someone she cared about.

Fleming had passed the recipe to Chick-fil-A’s corporate team around 2005. He never accepted payment, reportedly because he didn’t feel right profiting from something he knew wasn’t his original creation. Instead, he embraced the recognition that came with being credited as the sauce’s inventor.

Woodward was torn. She felt betrayed—but she also had a deep respect for Fleming. He had given her the space to create, to experiment, to fail until she got it right. And in the world of fast food, it wasn’t surprising that a teenage girl’s contribution had been erased.

So she stayed silent.

Fast forward to today. Woodward, now an accomplished model, marketing executive, and entrepreneur, finds herself at a Chick-fil-A again—this time with her daughter.

As they sit and watch the bustling lunch crowd, her daughter nudges her and grins.

"Mom, if all these people here just knew—you were standing right here."

Of all the things Woodward has accomplished, her daughter is most fascinated by the sauce.

And maybe that’s because the story of the sauce has never truly been told. Until now.

For years, rumors have circulated about how Chick-fil-A Sauce was created—one of the most famous being that an employee accidentally spilled barbecue sauce into honey mustard.

“That never happened,” Woodward says. “The full reason behind the birth of the sauce has never been told.”

Her original sauce was thinner, fresher, and had to be refrigerated—nothing like the mass-produced version sold today. Chick-fil-A may have bottled it, branded it, and built an empire on it, but it started with a 15-year-old girl in a mall food court, staying late after shifts to perfect something she simply wanted to get right.

Chick-fil-A once acknowledged Woodward’s impact. A corporate newsletter article titled "A Chick-fil-A Beauty” celebrated her modeling success and confirmed her time working at the restaurant. 

But when it comes to the sauce itself? No recognition. No credit. No paycheck.

And yet, her story is everywhere. It’s in every packet of sauce. In every order of nuggets. In every customer who’s ever said, “I don’t care about the chicken, just give me extra sauce.”

“It’s funny how life works,” Woodward reflects. “Something I created at 15 has become an American fast-food icon. And most people have no idea.”

But now, they do.

0
Save

Opinions and Perspectives

Get Free Access To Our Publishing Resources

Independent creators, thought-leaders, experts and individuals with unique perspectives use our free publishing tools to express themselves and create new ideas.

Start Writing