Sign up to see more
SignupAlready a member?
LoginBy continuing, you agree to Sociomix's Terms of Service, Privacy Policy
By continuing, you agree to Sociomix's Terms of Service, Privacy Policy
Fans of the Disney+ series The Mandalorian are well acquainted with Gina Carano’s supporting role on the show as Cara Dune. Dune played a heavy role in the series’ first season which granted the character a large fan following, and Carano fair wages ranging from $25k-$50k per episode. But despite the love from fans her screen-time during season 2 seemed to lessen, and now we know why.
Due to Carano’s repertoire of insensitive social media posts, the actress was recently fired from her part in Disney and LucasFilm’s Star Wars endeavors, ending her role on The Mandalorian, and scrapping what would’ve been a Cara Dune spin-off show.
Gina isn't the first actor to be let go due to controversial comments on the internet, and she won’t be the last. Her feud with LucasFilm over her social media presence had been churning for months, collecting a handful of posts that mocked mask-wearing during the covid-19 pandemic, compared being a Republican to being Jewish during the Holocaust, and displayed transphobia.
Supporters of Carano, such as Twitter user @RandomMnky, continue to state that Carano was taken out of context, saying that she “Did not post anything offensive” and that Disney is using their corporate power to “attack women.” They also criticize Disney’s left-wing preferences, which some claim have led to the firing of numerous entertainment workers in the past.
Disney’s political preferences remain unclear, but their firing of those with poor social media history does indicate a desire to keep their hands clean. Marvel Studios icon James Gunn went through a similar maze with Disney back in 2018 when an insensitive tweet caused his firing from his directorial position on Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3. He has since been reinstated.
Despite the controversy, Disney stands by their decision to remove Gina Carano from their Star Wars plans and has stated that they have no intention of recasting her character or moving forward with her spin-off show.
Fans plead on social media to recast her character, but, frankly, there’s no need.
The Mandalorian season 2 finale marked a checkpoint for creator Jon Favreau's epic series, and, due to the Christmas 2021 premiere of its spin-off series The Book of Boba Fett, we don’t expect to see season 3 until 2022.
The firing of Carano comes strangely well-timed for the exit of her beloved character Cara Dune and is best left open-ended rather than recast.
Gina doesn't believe that she deserved to be fired, and plans to fight back against Disney and Hollywood cancel culture.
Carano has said that she’ll be interviewed by Ben Shapiro and The Daily Wire regarding her expulsion from one of the most successful TV shows in recent memory, and one of the biggest franchises of all time.
Not only that, but she also announced that she and The Daily Wire will be producing a feature film together in which Carano will star. The team-up is an effort to help Gina reclaim her position in Hollywood, and keep her working.
Both Carano and Shapiro have expressed excitement over their future partnership, and distaste for Hollywood “cancel culture.”
Carano states: “I am sending out a direct message of hope to everyone living in fear of cancellation by the totalitarian mob...They can’t cancel us if we don’t let them.”
Carano stretched her interview time as long as she could, speaking with Shapiro for over an hour. She had a lot to say.
When asked about her “beep/bop/boop” Twitter bio in reference to people stating their preferred pronouns, Carano claimed it had “zero to do with trying to go after the transgender community” and that she “would never do that.”
She claimed the Twitter bio was a joke, showing that she “can put whatever [she] want[s] in her bio.” She compared it to an action taken by an unnamed Twitter user writing “trash panda” as their pronoun.
In regards to her social media posts warning of voter fraud during the 2020 presidential election, Carano said that it was meant to address concerns she had obtained during her own voting experience.
“I can’t even remember if there was a signature required,” she said, claiming that the poll workers hadn’t properly checked her identification and instead told her to “just go.” She also expressed concerns about masks concealing people's identities at the polls, claiming once again that poll workers didn’t authenticate her ID.
In one of her more controversial posts, Carano showed a vintage photo of a Jewish woman running from antisemites. The photo was paired with a caption that read: "How is [this] any different from hating someone for their political views?" The post led many to interpret it as her comparing being Republican to being a Holocaust victim.
Carano explained that the post was meant to stick up for those too “afraid to speak” and are “bullied” for their political beliefs.
Shapiro interjects, saying: “it was obvious the post was not anti-Semitic...what happened to Jews was evil, and this should never happen again, and that's why you should be careful about how you treat your neighbor.”
To this, Carano agreed, reinforcing the caption of her original post which reads: “Jews were beaten in the streets, not by N-a-z-i soldiers but by their neighbors.” She went on to address the people who vilified the post by saying: “why don’t you do your homework a little better?”
Shapiro asked how Disney and Lucasfilm had treated her leading up to her firing, and she responded by saying that executives were “slandering [her]” and only read “two words” of an apology she had written before deeming it not good enough.
Carano likened her final months with Disney and Lucasfilm to being “head-hunt[ed]” which is a boxing/fighting expression used when opponents unfairly aim for the head instead of the body.
It was briefly mentioned that her co-star, Pedro Pascal, on The Mandalorian also had a history of insensitive posts, but that he hadn’t received the backlash she was receiving now.
Gina Carano will not be returning to The Mandalorian as long as Disney and Lucasfilm stand their ground, but is she in the right, or is Disney?
It's a fact that Gina was pressured by Disney and Lucasfilm executives to form an apology, and discovered her own firing on social media, not from her employer.
It's also true that her social media posts offended a large number of individuals regardless of her intent.
So, should all charges brought against her be dropped? Probably not. But does her firing suggest Disney’s habit of firing employees without taking a minute to breathe? Maybe.
Her comments about being bullied by Disney don't match up with what we know happened.
This will probably help her career with certain audiences, but it's burned a lot of bridges.
The fact she compared typical political disagreements to the Holocaust shows poor judgment.
She seems to have confused freedom of speech with freedom from consequences.
I'm just sad we won't get to see where they were planning to take her character.
This whole situation is a perfect example of why celebrities need social media managers.
Disney could have handled the firing better, but they made the right decision.
Looking back, there were warning signs about her social media behavior long before this.
The whole mess has overshadowed what was actually a pretty good performance on the show.
She gained a lot of fans from The Mandalorian. What a waste of that goodwill.
Being afraid to speak up about political views isn't the same as systematic genocide. Period.
I think Disney made the right call for their brand, even if the execution was messy.
The contrast between her and James Gunn's response to controversy is really striking.
It's sad that she took such a great opportunity and threw it away over social media.
Her explanation about the voter ID situation doesn't really hold up under scrutiny.
The Holocaust post wasn't just offensive, it showed a real lack of historical understanding.
I'm curious about what her castmates think about all this. They've been pretty quiet.
I respected her more before I read her actual posts. They weren't taken out of context at all.
A $25-50k per episode paycheck is hard to walk away from over some social media posts.
The way she handled the pronouns situation showed a real lack of understanding.
I've followed her MMA career and she's always been outspoken. This shouldn't surprise anyone.
The support she's getting from certain groups tells you everything about how polarizing this issue is.
It's fascinating how one role can make or break an actor's career these days.
The whole voter fraud posts were just unnecessary. Why risk your career over that?
Her comments about being headhunted by Disney execs seem paranoid to me.
I wonder if Disney would have handled this differently if The Mandalorian wasn't such a huge success.
The fact that she's teaming up with Ben Shapiro shows exactly where she stands politically.
Reading through her explanations, it seems like she was trying to be provocative rather than actually hateful.
Social media has become such a minefield for public figures. One wrong post and it's over.
Honestly, I'm more disappointed about losing the character than the actor.
The timing with The Book of Boba Fett actually works out perfectly for writing her out naturally.
I wish they'd recast the role. Cara Dune was a great character independent of the actor.
Her new film project seems like a direct response to cancel culture. Smart move commercially.
The fact that Disney didn't even read her full apology before rejecting it says a lot about their approach.
Watching her interview, you can tell she feels genuinely persecuted, which is ironic given her posts.
The Holocaust comparison was where she really crossed the line for me. Some things you just don't joke about.
I feel like this whole situation could have been handled better on both sides.
The beep/bop/boop thing might have been meant as a joke, but it came across as really dismissive of trans issues.
Her voter fraud claims were particularly problematic given the timing and political climate.
I'm more interested in what this means for The Mandalorian going forward. How will they explain her absence?
The comparison between her and Pedro Pascal's social media posts is interesting. Seems like a double standard.
Let's be honest, if she had just apologized sincerely, this probably would have blown over.
She went from making $25-50k per episode to potentially losing her entire career. That must be tough.
Looking at the timeline, it seems Disney gave her multiple chances to course correct before taking action.
The whole situation makes me uncomfortable. We're getting to a point where actors can't express any views at all.
Having watched her interview with Shapiro, I can see she genuinely didn't think she was being offensive.
People keep saying she was cancelled but actions have consequences, especially when you represent a family-friendly brand.
The spin-off show getting cancelled is the biggest loss here. That could have been interesting.
I agree that companies should have standards, but where do we draw the line on policing personal opinions?
That comment about masks during covid was particularly tone deaf given how many people were suffering.
The show will be fine without her, but I'll miss seeing a strong female character who wasn't just there for eye candy.
Her partnership with The Daily Wire is smart from a career perspective. She's found her audience.
The fact she found out about her firing through social media rather than directly from Disney seems unprofessional to me.
Anyone else find it concerning that Disney seems to monitor their actors social media so closely?
I just don't get why celebrities can't stay off social media if they know it might impact their career.
The way she doubled down instead of apologizing really didn't help her case.
Interesting that James Gunn got reinstated but she didn't. Makes you wonder what happened behind the scenes.
I've worked in corporate entertainment and trust me, these decisions aren't made lightly. There must have been multiple warnings.
What bothers me most is how she compared being Republican to being Jewish during the Holocaust. That's just incredibly insensitive.
The timing worked out well for the story at least. Season 2's ending provides a natural exit point for her character.
Actually I think Disney made the right call. Her posts went way beyond just expressing political views.
I understand Disney wanting to protect their brand image, but firing someone over social media posts without proper discussion seems harsh.