4 Delicious Shakes That Can Replace A Meal

Sometimes, you just need a quick pick-me-up. Find out how to get the calories and nutrients you need with a sweet twist.

Life can be fast-paced at times. You don't always have the liberty of putting together a full meal. Even when you do, you might not have the time to factor in the calorie count or nutrients. There are pre-made meal replacement shakes you can buy at the store, but these tend to have excessive amounts of sugar.

Ultimately, it would be better for your body to whip up your own version at home. In cases like these, meal replacement shakes are life-savers. They are tasty and easy to make. When prepared with the right ingredients, they can fill you up and give your body everything it needs to function properly.

Start with these four delicious recipes if you're looking for a milkshake to replace a meal.

1. Banana Shake

Meal replacement shake
Image Source: Cuisinart

Bananas are a common ingredient in most smoothies and shakes, but they also pack a powerful punch on their own. This fruit boasts many dietary benefits. According to this food profile by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, bananas are full of essential nutrients such as potassium and fiber and contain enough protein to keep you full. Not to mention, the list of possible flavor combinations is endless; It goes with almost everything!

I really enjoy this banana protein shake by Fit Foodie Finds. Ingredients are kept to a minimum in this tasty recipe. A hint of vanilla extract gives this drink just the right amount of sweetness. It is a shake I can throw together quickly with minimal effort, and one that keeps me full for hours.

What you'll need:

  • ¾ c Greek yogurt (frozen, cubed)
  • 2 c sliced bananas (frozen
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 2 c milk
  • ¼ c vanilla protein powder

Lastly, blend! I use slightly less milk than the recipe calls for since I like a thicker shake. The recipe recommends unsweetened vanilla almond milk, but I prefer the sweetened kind.

I only use the vanilla extract whenever I'm using regular milk — using sweetened Vanilla Almond Breeze gives the shake all the sweetness I need. I don't always add the protein powder either. It tastes wonderful with or without.

2. Chocolate Shake

Shakes to replace a meal

Many people think they have to avoid chocolate entirely due to sugar, but when used correctly, it can be a sweet addition to almost any meal replacement shake. The trick is to use cocoa powder instead of store-bought chocolate syrup. Chocolate syrup is full of high fructose corn syrup and other things we don't want in our bodies.

On the other hand, pure cocoa powder has real health advantages. Per this study published in the National Library of Medicine, it has the capability to reduce blood pressure. Additionally, this study published in the same journal suggests cocoa might even aid in weight loss.

Finding one chocolate shake combination that works for you can take time, especially when there are so many recipes out there. After trying a handful, I found myself settling on this "mockshake" from Snappy Gourmet.

What you'll need:

  • 1 medium banana (sliced, frozen)
  • 1 c ice
  • 1 c milk
  • 3 tbsp unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 1 tbsp nut butter
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract

Blend! Although the original recipe calls for almond milk and almond butter, these can be swapped for the milk and/or nut butter of your choice to create delicious variations of the shake. Add a dollop of whipped cream, and you've got a healthy spin on a classic.

3. Peanut Butter Shake

Shakes to replace a meal

Peanut butter is my favorite way to get protein. I can't get enough of its creamy, slightly salty goodness. It's a dense food packed with proteins and good fats — perfect for meal replacement. However, you have to be careful when choosing which kind of peanut butter you're using. Like most store-bought items, name-brand peanut butter can contain added sugars and fats. I would recommend an organic brand with minimal ingredients.

Or, you could make your own peanut butter. It's quick and easy!

Surprisingly, it's a bit hard to find a recipe for a healthy, plain peanut butter shake with actual peanut butter in it — almost all of the ones I found either substituted the PB for peanut butter powder or had some sort of chocolate addition. In the end, I settled on my own variation of this Peanut Butter Cup Protein Shake recipe from Fountain Avenue Kitchen.

What you'll need:

  • ½ c milk
  • ½ c low-fat vanilla yogurt
  • 1 scoop protein powder
  • 1 medium banana (chunked, frozen)
  • 1 tbsp peanut butter
  • 1 c ice cubes

You guessed it — Blend! Again, I don't always use protein powder, but when I do, I use chocolate powder as the original recipe recommends. Let's face it, chocolate and peanut butter are a duo to die for. When I don't use the powder, I usually use a tad bit more peanut butter to compensate.

4. Coffee Shake

Shakes to replace a meal

This shake will fill you up and give you a boost at the same time. While mixed coffee drinks can be high in sugar and calories, coffee itself has less than 5 calories according to the USDA. Depending on what other ingredients you add to your drink, you can get your caffeine for the day from a healthy, low-calorie shake. I enjoy this Iced Coffee Protein Shake recipe from Simply Happy Foodie.

What you'll need:

  • 1½ c ice
  • ¾ c milk
  • 1 banana (frozen)
  • 1 scoop protein powder
  • 1 c coffee (cooled)
  • 1-2 tbsp raw honey

Now blend! You can tamper with the amount of cooled coffee you add depending on how strong you want the taste to come through. To top it off, the addition of honey gives it the sweetness it needs to negate the bitter aftertaste of the coffee. The recipe says the honey is optional, but I think it's a must. I like to experiment using different roasts of coffee as well as different blends.


My favorite thing about these 4 ingredients is that they taste amazing on their own, but they also taste absolutely divine when mixed. A Chocolate Banana Peanut Butter Shake? Yes, please!

If you browse the web for different recipes for these shakes, you'll find that the ingredients are often mixed together. Banana is essential for the structure of a shake, especially when you aren't using ice cream as a base.

Peanut butter adds creaminess and thickness, making you more full. Chocolate and coffee are both delicious flavor additions, adding a kick to your shake and giving you the boost you need to make it through the day.

If you are just starting on your meal replacement journey, you can't go wrong with these ingredients or any combination of them.

432
Save

Opinions and Perspectives

Maya commented Maya 3 years ago

Great recipes but remember to listen to your body's needs too.

4
CelesteM commented CelesteM 3 years ago

These are lifesavers during busy work weeks.

8
JadeFashions commented JadeFashions 3 years ago

I layer and freeze ingredients in bags for easy morning prep.

6
DavidBrown commented DavidBrown 3 years ago

The coffee shake has replaced my morning Starbucks run. Saving money and calories!

2
ZinniaJ commented ZinniaJ 3 years ago

These work great for post-workout recovery too.

5
RyanBarnes commented RyanBarnes 3 years ago

Adding ginger to the banana shake gives it a nice kick.

1
NoahHall commented NoahHall 3 years ago

They're convenient but I miss chewing actual food sometimes.

1
ActiveSoul commented ActiveSoul 3 years ago

Started making these for breakfast and noticed more energy throughout the day.

7
WesleyM commented WesleyM 3 years ago

Love how customizable these are to different dietary needs.

8
MaeveX commented MaeveX 3 years ago

The peanut butter and banana combo is unbeatable.

2
Claire commented Claire 3 years ago

I prep ingredients the night before. Makes mornings so much easier.

4
Aurora_Hope commented Aurora_Hope 3 years ago

Great shakes but be careful with portion sizes. Calories can add up fast.

4
VivienneH commented VivienneH 3 years ago

These recipes helped me break my fast food breakfast habit.

5
SarahKing commented SarahKing 3 years ago

Using frozen cauliflower makes them extra thick without adding calories.

1
Valentina7 commented Valentina7 3 years ago

I mix and match ingredients from different recipes. So many possibilities!

7
Mia_88 commented Mia_88 3 years ago

The coffee shake is perfect for summer mornings when it's too hot for hot coffee.

5
Faye_Mystic commented Faye_Mystic 3 years ago

These are good but nothing beats a real meal when you have the time.

6
Aurora_Shine commented Aurora_Shine 3 years ago

Found that adding avocado makes them super creamy.

0
AmeliaW commented AmeliaW 3 years ago

I double the recipe and share with my partner. Great couple's breakfast!

4
AnyaM commented AnyaM 3 years ago

These saved me during a kitchen renovation. Quick and no cooking needed!

7
Blythe_Dream commented Blythe_Dream 3 years ago

Anyone tried using coconut milk? Wondering how it affects the taste.

4
TessaM commented TessaM 3 years ago

The banana shake is too sweet for me even without added sweeteners.

8
Yoga_Flow-Daily commented Yoga_Flow-Daily 3 years ago

Been having these for lunch at work. So much better than fast food.

6
ReaganGarza commented ReaganGarza 3 years ago

I appreciate that these use real ingredients instead of artificial stuff.

1
LaceyM commented LaceyM 3 years ago

The chocolate shake with coffee added is like a healthy mocha. So good!

3
DevonT commented DevonT 3 years ago

Try adding more protein powder or nut butter for staying power.

2

These are great but I still feel hungry after about 2 hours.

8
WarpDriveX commented WarpDriveX 3 years ago

I add some cinnamon to the banana shake. Takes it to another level!

4
Hersh_Headlines commented Hersh_Headlines 4 years ago

The peanut butter shake is basically dessert for breakfast and I'm here for it.

4
ConnorCooks commented ConnorCooks 4 years ago

Try cutting the bananas into smaller pieces before freezing. Works much better!

5
Colette_Hope commented Colette_Hope 4 years ago

My blender struggles with frozen bananas. Any tips?

8
LandonFox commented LandonFox 4 years ago

I'm impressed by how filling these are. Usually skeptical of liquid meals but these work.

2
Ivory_Glow commented Ivory_Glow 4 years ago

Using frozen coffee cubes instead of regular ice in the coffee shake is brilliant!

4
LeahMason commented LeahMason 4 years ago

These are perfect for busy mornings but I wouldn't rely on them for every meal.

6
KevinBlack commented KevinBlack 4 years ago

Have you tried adding oats? Makes them even more filling.

0

The coffee shake is great but I'd suggest cold brew to avoid bitterness.

8
Bianco_Brief commented Bianco_Brief 4 years ago

I batch prep the dry ingredients in containers, makes morning routine so much faster.

4
SilentVoyager99 commented SilentVoyager99 4 years ago

These have helped me stop skipping breakfast. Quick and filling!

4
TheShadowLord commented TheShadowLord 4 years ago

Anyone tried using almond butter instead of peanut butter? Wondering if it's worth the extra cost.

5
Teresa-Hale commented Teresa-Hale 4 years ago

The chocolate shake really satisfies my dessert cravings without the guilt.

8
Autumn_Sun commented Autumn_Sun 4 years ago

These recipes are good starting points but I've found adding greens makes them more nutritionally complete.

6
TheCodeNomad commented TheCodeNomad 4 years ago

Using cold brew coffee in the coffee shake makes it so much smoother.

7
TimeWarpX commented TimeWarpX 4 years ago

I switched from pre-made shakes to these and noticed a huge difference in energy levels.

4
JunoH commented JunoH 4 years ago

Never thought of freezing Greek yogurt cubes before. Game changer for thickness!

7
Jessica-Rose commented Jessica-Rose 4 years ago

These are great but careful with portion sizes. Easy to go overboard with calories even with healthy ingredients.

2
Selma_Breeze commented Selma_Breeze 4 years ago

I add chia seeds to all of these for extra nutrition. They blend right in!

3
Scarlett commented Scarlett 4 years ago

The peanut butter shake has become my post-workout staple. Really helps with muscle recovery.

5
Couric_Coverage commented Couric_Coverage 4 years ago

Love these recipes but wish there were more options without bananas.

5
JasonLearns commented JasonLearns 4 years ago

Frozen mango works great as a banana substitute! Gives similar creaminess.

1
ToriWanders commented ToriWanders 4 years ago

I'm allergic to bananas. Any suggestions for substitutes that will still give the right texture?

6
Lana_Solar commented Lana_Solar 4 years ago

Can we talk about how expensive protein powder is? Any recommendations for budget-friendly brands?

6
GhostlyWhispers commented GhostlyWhispers 4 years ago

These are good but let's not pretend they're the same as eating real food. I see them as occasional alternatives.

6
Goodman_Guide commented Goodman_Guide 4 years ago

I've experimented with different protein powders and found that whey isolate works best in these recipes.

2
Lillian_White commented Lillian_White 4 years ago

The honey in the coffee shake is definitely not optional for me. Makes such a difference!

7

I was skeptical about meal replacement shakes but these changed my mind. They're actually satisfying.

8
DigitalVisionary commented DigitalVisionary 4 years ago

Anyone else notice these keep them fuller than store-bought meal replacement shakes?

8
QuantumGlitchX commented QuantumGlitchX 4 years ago

The banana shake recipe has too much protein powder for my taste. I cut it in half and it's perfect.

3
Eliza_Star commented Eliza_Star 4 years ago

My kids love these too. Finally found something nutritious they'll actually drink.

5
RaelynnS commented RaelynnS 4 years ago

I've been combining the chocolate and peanut butter recipes. It's like a healthy Reese's in shake form!

4

The coffee shake saved my mornings! No more expensive coffee runs and I'm getting protein at the same time.

2
Ariana commented Ariana 4 years ago

You could try using half a banana and adding some cauliflower. Sounds weird but it works!

2
Isikoff_Insights commented Isikoff_Insights 4 years ago

These are great but I worry about the sugar content from bananas. Any suggestions for lower sugar alternatives?

6
Savannah commented Savannah 4 years ago

Making my own peanut butter made such a difference! Store-bought versions just don't compare.

7
AlyssaF commented AlyssaF 4 years ago

I love the peanut butter shake but found it too thick. Adding a bit more milk helped perfect the consistency.

4
LilithM commented LilithM 4 years ago

Has anyone tried freezing these in batches? I'm wondering if I can prep them for the whole week.

1
Norah_Bloom commented Norah_Bloom 4 years ago

Thanks for mentioning the tip about using pure cocoa powder instead of chocolate syrup. I never realized how much sugar was in the store-bought stuff.

4
FutureProphet commented FutureProphet 4 years ago

The chocolate shake recipe is amazing! I added a handful of spinach and you can't even taste it. Great way to sneak in extra vegetables.

1
Gianna99 commented Gianna99 4 years ago

I respectfully disagree. When made with the right ingredients, these shakes can provide all the nutrients we need.

6

Am I the only one who thinks meal replacement shakes can't really substitute a proper meal? Our bodies need real food.

7

The coffee shake has become my morning go-to. It's like a healthier version of those expensive coffee shop drinks.

6
AvaM commented AvaM 4 years ago

Does anyone know if these shakes work well for weight loss? I'm trying to cut calories but still stay energized throughout the day.

0
Emmeline_Magic commented Emmeline_Magic 4 years ago

I tried the banana shake this morning and it kept me full until lunch. Love how simple the ingredients are!

6
PixelKnight commented PixelKnight 4 years ago

These shakes look delicious! I've been looking for healthier alternatives to my usual breakfast and these might be perfect.

2

Get Free Access To Our Publishing Resources

Independent creators, thought-leaders, experts and individuals with unique perspectives use our free publishing tools to express themselves and create new ideas.

Start Writing